Legal experts warn of consequences as Ruto defies Cabinet gender ruling
Politics
By
Okumu Modachi
| Nov 22, 2026
The expiry of the 120-day deadline set by the courts for President William Ruto to reconstitute his Cabinet has thrust Kenya into an unprecedented constitutional dilemma, with the country potentially operating under an Executive whose composition has been declared unconstitutional.
Despite the timelines issued by the High Court, the Attorney-General moved to challenge the decision only after the deadline had elapsed, raising questions about the Government’s respect for court orders and the rule of law.
The dispute now extends beyond the two-thirds gender principle to the authority under which Cabinet Secretaries continue discharging their duties.
READ MORE
Why Kenya urgently needs an industry-driven industrial policy
Kenyan banks' regional bet pays off as subsidiaries power profits
New sports tourism venture aims to draw international football fans to Kenya
All set for Kenya's first commercial oil output
African fintech start-ups set for Sh3.38bn investment boost
Construction authority exposes gaps after 72 buildings collapse
US beats China in race for Kenya's Sh8 trillion Mrima Hill mineral project
StanChart Kenya profit jumps to Sh10.5bn despite total income drop
NSE extends trading hours in push for global status
Why combining talent and technology is key to Kenya's development
The High Court, in a judgment delivered on June 30, declared the composition of the Cabinet unconstitutional for violating Article 27(8) of the Constitution, which requires that no more than two-thirds of members of appointive bodies be of the same gender.
The court gave the President 120 days to reconstitute the Cabinet and comply with the constitutional requirement, with the deadline expiring on October 28.
The Government’s attempt to suspend the judgment also suffered a setback at the Court of Appeal after a three-judge bench questioned why the application excluded the Senate and Transparency International Kenya, both of which participated in the original proceedings.
State lawyer Christopher Marwa described the omission as a clerical error and sought time to amend the application, but the judges termed it fundamental.
Justice Lucy Njuguna told him: “Leaving out parties to an application is a fundamental error. And it is not a simple mistake.”
The State has since refiled the application.
What began as a dispute over constitutional representation threatens to become a wider test of presidential power, some experts now warn, arguing that decisions made by the Cabinet from this point onwards could face legal scrutiny.
The uncertainty risks litigation, prolonged disruption of services for citizens and declining confidence in public institutions.
Senior Counsel Paul Muite believes the moment demands more than judicial warnings, arguing that courts must demonstrate that their orders bind even the most powerful offices.
According to Muite, judges should move beyond threats of contempt and impose meaningful consequences on officials who disregard court directions.
“The Judges need to up their game beyond merely threatening contempt, and when senior government officials finally appear before them, they meekly let them off with a warning or a slap on the wrist,” he told The Sunday Standard.
"Judges now need to deny A.G. representing the Gov audience in Courts, send CSs to prison and declare ALL government decisions by this illegal Gov null and void."
Advocate and former Committee of Experts commissioner Bob Mkangi sees the standoff as potentially reaching the President’s tenure.
He argues that continued failure to obey the judgment could provide grounds for impeachment under Article 145(1) of the Constitution, which provides for impeachment on grounds of gross violation of the Constitution.
“If the president fails to comply with the order, this will invite any member of the National Assembly to commence impeachment proceedings against the president,” Mkangi said.
Impeachment is not automatic, he observes. However, the possibility gives the dispute a political dimension and puts pressure on lawmakers.
Lawyer Ndegwa Njiru says the President should “swallow the humble pie” and reconstitute the Cabinet in accordance with the High Court decision. If he refuses, Parliament should initiate impeachment proceedings.
Njiru also expressed concern that major transactions undertaken by the current Cabinet could be challenged, particularly those involving public assets.
He cites a possible sale of State-owned corporations or disposal of government shares in Kenya Pipeline Company and Safaricom as examples of decisions that could become embroiled in litigation.
“I want to caution Kenyans, investors and other parties against rushing into major transactions with the government, particularly those involving public assets, because their legality could be challenged in court,” he said.
Uncertainty could delay investments, complicate negotiations and expose the State to financial claims. Even if decisions are ultimately upheld, litigation could delay contracts and raise costs, he says.
However, not all legal minds agree that the expiry of the deadline renders every Cabinet action invalid or places the country on the brink of paralysis.
Lawyer and political analyst Javas Bigambo offers a contrasting interpretation, arguing that the judgment is primarily a compliance issue concerning the Cabinet’s gender composition, rather than an automatic declaration that every decision made by its members is void.
"There is no other consequence. Because remember there is what you call presidential prerogative. It is the prerogative of the president to constitute a cabinet," he opined, arguing that Parliament should enact legislation giving practical effect to the two-thirds gender principle.
"In the absence of such statute, it tells you that while courts may have pronounced itself as such, which still behoves the executive to reorganise cabinet in respect to compliance, it is important that parliament develops a law on gender parity."
At the same time, he argues that the country is "factually and practically" in the electioneering period and that, while compliance with the two-thirds gender rule is important, "there is not much that cabinet is going to do between now and the next election."
Lawyer Adrian Kamotho disagrees with Bigambo, arguing that there is “absolutely no crisis” and that Parliament should provide the formula for achieving the two-thirds gender principle.
“There is absolutely no crisis, and the same is being manufactured. He maintained that Parliament should provide the formula for achieving compliance with the two-thirds gender principle," he said.
Their position invokes continuity, although critics say it cannot override a binding court order.
The Law Society of Kenya has taken a harder line. LSK president Charles Kanjama said the court order had neither been stayed, reviewed nor overturned, leaving the President without justification for failing to implement it.
“The President of Kenya is now in violation of the Constitution pursuant to an express court order. The Cabinet of Kenya is unconstitutional and its actions and decisions are susceptible to being deemed null and void,” Kanjama said.
The society urged the petitioners to return to court and seek enforcement, offering to join the proceedings. Kanjama warned that the matter should not continue for “even one extra week”, saying prolonged defiance would signify unacceptable impunity in the Executive.
Former Chief Justice David Maraga framed the dispute as a threat to constitutional order.
“Defying the courts is an explicit invitation to anarchy,” he said, urging the President to comply or resign. Maraga further argued that failure to comply with the Constitution makes subsequent Cabinet actions a legal nullity.
Petitioner Saitabao Ole Kanchory says continued defiance undermines public confidence and risks setting a precedent that the Government can disregard judicial decisions without consequence.