A thrilling duel in perfect conditions saw Mutiso almost catch Kipruto with a late burst in the final metres of what was the closest finish in New York Marathon history.
Kipruto crossed the line in a time of two hours eight minutes and nine seconds, with Mutiso 0.16secs behind.
Kenya's Albert Korir, the 2021 New York winner, was third in 2:08:57.
READ MORE
UAE, African Union deepen partnership on peace, trade and technology
Kenya eyes tenth straight senior women's team title at World Cross
Full list: The 66 global bodies US has withdrawn from
Will Kenya's Ebenyo stop Uganda's Kiplimo in Saturday's World Cross battle in Florida?
KUCCPS opens KMTC placement for March 2026 intake
When football's playbook becomes leadership strategy
Where's next? Trump eyes new targets after Venezuela
Ruto's men on the spot over missing road allocations
Hope and fear to dominate economic prospects of 2026
2026 budget aims high but struggles to maintain proper fiscal discipline